Theo went to Gabriel's house to show what a dirtbag Gabriel was. In Part V, we learn the real story from Alicia's diary. Theo is the mysterious man Alicia had seen hanging around the house and who showed up the night of Gabriel's death). In other words, all the sections about Kathy, her cheating, and her lover were in the past. It's Gabriel, and his wife Alicia is there, too.

In Part IV, Theo goes to the house of Kathy's lover. Theo sees that she was injected by morphine, tells the others about Christian and Christian is arrested. Before he can follow up, the next day Alicia is found in a coma. She says that man showed up, tied them up and shot Gabriel. Alicia tells him about the night of Gabriel's death. When Theo brings this up to Alicia, she finally begins to speak. This leads Theo to learn more about Alicia's prior trauma (after her mother's suicide, Alicia father wished Alicia had died instead). Christian didn't tell anyone because it had been an unlicensed practice. Theo also learns that Christian (Alicia's doctor before Theo) had actually treated her even before Gabriel's death. In Part III, Theo follows Kathy and sees that her lover is also married. Meanwhile, Theo discovers his wife Kathy is cheating on him. She was later saved, but never spoke again. Theo also learns that 'Alcestis' is the story of a Greek goddess who was sent to Hades (death) in the place of her husband. And Jean owns the gallery Alicia's art was in, but she had been planning on switching galleries.) Alicia and her neighbor had also noticed a man (Alicia had suspected Max or Jean) hanging outside her house in the time prior to Gabriel's death. (Theo finds out Alicia had once been assaulted by her brother in law, Max.

In Part II, Theo tries to treat Alicia by reducing her meds, allowing her to paint and talking to outside sources to learn more. Theo learns about Alicia's prior trauma, stemming from her mother suicide attempt with a young Alicia in the car. Six years later, Theo takes her case over from another doctor, Christian. Alicia was found guilty and sent to a mental facility. She has not spoken a word since, though she produced one last painting (entitled 'Alcestis'). Her husband was found tied up and shot dead.

Book the silent patient